What Is A Liquidator’s Duty Of Transparency?

Duty To Creditors In A Liquidation

Liquidator duty of transparency to creditors is at the heart of insolvency procedures. Creditors have the right to know what the Liquidator is doing, how he or she is doing what they are doing and when they might see the benefits.

Insolvency Is For The Benefit Of Creditors

Creditors are what insolvency procedures are all about. Without creditors insolvency as a process would not exist. Insolvency is therefore not for the benefit of Liquidators notwithstanding that they rank ahead of creditors in the statutory order of payment in insolvency proceedings.

Insolvency Is All About The Creditors

Whilst insolvency is to assist Debtors and Directors, that is so that they can deal properly and lawfully with creditors.

Regulatory Objective Of Insolvency Practitioners

The Insolvency Act 1986 has regulatory objectives. Section 391C of the Insolvency Act 1986 refers to the following regulatory objective:

… promoting the maximisation of the value of returns to creditors and promptness in making those returns

The Liquidator enters office as a stranger to the insolvency; creditors do not. Without transparency afforded to creditors and engagement with them, a Liquidator may not learn the full facts about a company in Liquidation’s affairs.

Legal Duty Of Transparency To Creditors

Annual Progress Reports To Creditors

The primary Liquidator duty of transparency to creditors is the content required in the annual progress reports that a Liquidator must provide. Rule 18.3 of the Insolvency (England And Wales) Rules 2016 sets out details of the same, which includes:

(e) details of progress during the period of the report, including a summary account of receipts and payments during the period of the report

Regulatory Duty Of Transparency To Creditors

A Liquidator’s duties are many and varied but transparency for creditors is arguably at the summit of the same. However, where does the duty of transparency arise from?

Insolvency Code Of Ethics

The answer starts from the Insolvency Code Of Ethics and what it says in the transparency requirements of an Insolvency Practitioner:

… an Insolvency Practitioner in the role as office holder has a professional duty to report openly to those with an interest in the outcome of the insolvency. An Insolvency Practitioner should always report on his acts and dealings as fully as possible given the circumstances of the case, in a way that is transparent and understandable. An Insolvency Practitioner should bear in mind the expectations of others and what a reasonable and informed third party would consider appropriate.

Statement Of Insolvency Practice Number 2

Statement Of Insolvency Practice Number 2 refers to creditor reporting duties of a Liquidator as follows:

An office holder should report clearly on the steps taken in relation to investigations, and the outcomes …. Creditors should be given information regarding investigations, any action being taken, and whether funding is being provided by third parties; disclosure would be subject to considerations of privilege and confidentiality and whether investigations and litigation might be compromised.

Exceptions To The Duty Of Transparency

The duty of transparency is subject to some exceptions.

Legally Privileged Information

Documents subject to legal and professional privilege (“LPP”) outrank the Liquidator duty of transparency to creditors.

In most instances LPP is paramount and cannot be overridden even by the Court. LPP is deemed to be sacred.

Confidential Material

The Court can override confidentiality and order disclosure but it will be slow to do so as was noted for example only in the case of Green v Chubb and another [2015] EWHC 221 (Ch):

… confidentiality is not ordinarily overridden (but it may be)

Confidential material could be personal data disclosed but subject to the non-disclosure provisions in the Data Protection Act 2018. It can also arise by virtue of information that has been obtained under compulsion such as pursuant to an order of the Court under Section 236 of the Insolvency Act 1986. An example of the same might be the transcript of an interview of a Director of a company that has gone into Liquidation.

Oliver Elliot Comment

The Liquidator duty of transparency to creditors is a principle referred to in the Insolvency Code of Ethics. It therefore cannot be treated as some optional requirement.

It is however not an unqualified right that creditors have transparency. Certain matters will be confidential and not open for the Liquidator to disclose to creditors.

If the duty of transparency is considered to prejudice the future course of a Liquidation it appears that it will be for the Liquidator to properly put forward a reasoned position that conceivably goes beyond bare assertion to justify fettering the information afforded to creditors.

Are you a creditor looking to recover your money?

If you are a creditor of an insolvent company or a bankruptcy, Oliver Elliot can help you address your claim and concerns arising from the insolvency.

Find out how

Share This Page!

What Next?

Expert Advice Is Just A Click Away

If you have any questions in relation to Liquidator Duty Of Transparency To Creditors then contact us as soon as possible for advice. Oliver Elliot offers a fresh approach to insolvency and the liquidation of a company by offering specialist advice and services across a wide range of insolvency procedures.

Our expertise is at your fingertips.

By submitting this form you agree with the storage and handling of your data by Oliver Elliot. For more details, please read our Privacy Policy.

Disclaimer: Liquidator Duty Of Transparency

This page: Liquidator Duty Of Transparency To Creditors is not legal advice and should not be relied upon as such. This article Liquidator Duty Of Transparency To Creditors is provided for information purposes only. You can contact us on the specific facts of your case to obtain relevant advice via a Free Initial Consultation.

Recent Posts / View All Posts

Insolvency Service Talking Tough

Insolvency Service Talking Tough

| Liquidation | No Comments
The Insolvency Service Talking Tough? Boris Becker, once the world number one tennis player (winner of six Grand Slams) is now perhaps one of the most famous former tennis players…
Liquidator HMRC Tax Avoidance Claim

Blowing The Embers Of A Long-Abandoned Fire – Liquidator Tax Avoidance Claim

| Liquidation | No Comments
Liquidator Tax Avoidance Claim Overview A seemingly disappointing decision sprouted in the case of Hunt v Balfour-Lynn & Ors EWHC 784 (Ch) when a Liquidator tax avoidance claim did not…
Post Petition Payments In A Liquidation

Post Petition Payments In A Liquidation

| Liquidation | No Comments
Overview Of Liquidation Committee A Liquidation Committee is a number of the creditors of the company in Liquidation that in effect represent all of the creditors. Purpose Of A Liquidation…
Desire To Prefer

Desire To Prefer And Company Policy

| Liquidation | No Comments
Overview Of Desire To Prefer And Company Policy A case popped up on pancake Tuesday, Re De Weyer Ltd EWHC 395 (Ch) and at its heart was the desire to…